She went on about it being the best room in the house. Write paragraph responses to each of the following questions. Ironically, too, the community seems to embrace her more spontaneously and willingly as a stranger. Furthermore, Tony and his family offer her the chance to start anew in America. How are the traditional ethnic lines of Brooklyn beginning to break down in the s?

It was not just that she had no friends and family; it was rather that she was a ghost in this room, in the streets on the way to work, on the shop floor. She agrees to go with Jim because it is the easiest path for her at that moment, because the present Jim is more real to her than the absent Tony. Rather, Eilis lives too much in the present, too little in the future. By doing this, Eilis encouraged each of the men to love her. Furthermore, Tony and his family offer her the chance to start anew in America. After meeting a kind Italian-American boy, she plans an American future.

Though she is passive, she sees herself as a shadowy actor. She longs for her Irish home and the familiar.

brooklyn colm toibin essay vce

No products in the cart. In fact, it works so well that she has the following epiphany: By the end of the novel, we see Eilis for what she is.

Cambridge Checkpoints VCE Text Guides: Brooklyn by Colm Toibin – Nick Konstantatos – Google Books

And, as the train rolled past Macmine Bridge on its way towards Wexford, Eilis imagined the years ahead, when these words would come to mean less and less to the man who heard them and would come to mean more and more to herself. She only reveals to Rose in the middle of the paragraph that Tony is a plumber.

brooklyn colm toibin essay vce

She grows to be less defenceless, forming her own voice and becomes brave enough to defend the coloured customers from the ridicule of the boarders. Are these people you would want to meet? All of this putting out of mind thoughts of the future and people absent can only lead to problems.


When esaay, Nancy, George, and Jim head off to the beach, Eilis examines the surroundings as they go. She wondered if it was an act, but he was looking at her with an broolkyn so vulnerable that she, for a second, could not make her mind up what to do. Toibin exploits this by giving us so little of Eilis besides her seeming pliability.

Good intro – maybe you could suggest the fact that Eilis’ sense of identity in Brooklyn is never solidified due to her time there being interrupted by her return to Ireland a little earlier in the paragraph, Then you could go on to saying basically what you’ve said here – that, despite this, she experiences and begins to integrate herself into the Brooklyn way of life, ect basically it’ll just mean that you have a clear link to the question at the end of the intro – the question focuses on what assists her in regaining a sense of identity, not whether she does.

We first see it most clearly when Eilis, having been in America a short while, gets homesick. She would have to get on with her work it if was during the day and go back to sleep if it as during the night.

Search the forums now!

In narrative texts, characters embody values through their thoughts, feelings, attitudes, beliefs and actions. Furthermore, maybe try not to signpost so much in the intro – it sounds ab it awkward just because the sentences in an intro are so short.

For what she is thanking her is not clear. Your honest thoughts please! What enables her to eesay her sense of identity in Brooklyn? She obtains employment, but suffers severe homesickness as she settles into a ghetto-like Irish enclave in Brooklyn.


Brooklyn by Colm Toibin

Eilis senses that one of these two selves will necessarily pass. We are reminded that familiarity can help to overcome sadness.

Should Tony turn his head, she might be gone. Perhaps, though, it is also her sense of difference that now attracts him to Eilis, without which his desire and commitment may be reduced. Create a concept map for Eilis and one of the other main characters Minor toibim Minor characters receive less attention, but they can serve important functions such as: Does this reflect their relationship with Eilis? It is not only that Eilis avoids confrontation, but she tends to shield herself from the truth and, if she glimpses it brooilyn her best efforts, to hide it away somewhere away from tkibin conscious mind.

The subject is specific, the themes are general and are able to be related to common human experience. But as we also know, Jack soon cherishes his independence.

Brooklyn by Colm Toibin – English Works

When reading the text, you need to focus on the ways in which the author has created the characters by focusing on the following: As testimony to the transformative affect of Brooklyn, Tobin depicts Eilis as ambiguously tiobin a family member and an outsider. Jim, for example, becomes imbued with a sense of nostalgia that Tony will never have, because of the sense of loss and disappointment attached to their relationship.

Create two photomontages capturing what life was like in the s in Enniscorthy County Wexford and Brooklyn.